2020 Fiat 500 vs 2020 Toyota Yaris
The 2020 Fiat 500 and 2020 Toyota Yaris are both popular city cars in the European market, often compared for their compact size, urban agility, and efficiency. The Fiat 500 stands out with its iconic retro styling and fun-to-drive character, appealing to style-conscious buyers seeking a premium-feeling small car. In contrast, the Toyota Yaris is renowned for its reliability, fuel economy, and practicality, targeting those prioritizing long-term ownership costs and dependability.
These models compete directly in the B-segment, with the Fiat 500 emphasizing charm and personality while the Yaris focuses on no-nonsense functionality. Comparisons from expert reviews highlight the Fiat's peppier base engine options against the Yaris's superior efficiency and space, making them alternatives for city commuters weighing fun versus frugality.
These models compete directly in the B-segment, with the Fiat 500 emphasizing charm and personality while the Yaris focuses on no-nonsense functionality. Comparisons from expert reviews highlight the Fiat's peppier base engine options against the Yaris's superior efficiency and space, making them alternatives for city commuters weighing fun versus frugality.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Category | Fiat 500 | Toyota Yaris | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Performance | Fiat 500: 1.4L inline-4, 135 hp, manual transmission, FWD. | Toyota Yaris: 1.5L inline-4, 106 hp, manual transmission, FWD; some variants up to 85kW (114 hp). | A |
| Comfort | Fiat 500: Compact interior with 39.3in front headroom, 40.6in legroom; tighter rear space at 37.6in headroom, 33.3in legroom. | Toyota Yaris: Larger overall (3940mm length vs 3571mm), more rear legroom implied by 2550mm wheelbase vs 2300mm; better shoulder room. | B |
| Technology | Fiat 500: Basic features in 2020 models, with average fuel computer; limited advanced tech noted in reviews. | Toyota Yaris: Similar basic instrumentation, but longer warranty (5 years vs 3) and roadside assist suggest better support ecosystem. | Tie |
| Safety | Fiat 500: Standard city car safety, but shorter warranty and service intervals may impact long-term. | Toyota Yaris: Benefits from Toyota's strong safety reputation; 5-year warranty enhances peace of mind. | B |
| Practicality | Fiat 500: 185L boot, compact 3571mm length, low 123mm ground clearance; suits tight parking. | Toyota Yaris: 270L boot, longer 3940mm body, larger 36L tank for 1091km range vs 729km. | B |
| Running Costs | Fiat 500: 4.8L/100km combined (30 mpg), premium unleaded, 111g/km CO2, 12mo/15k km service. | Toyota Yaris: 3.3L/100km (33 mpg), regular unleaded, 76g/km CO2, same service interval. | B |
| Resale Value | Fiat 500: Shorter 3-year warranty may hurt retention; style aids appeal but reliability concerns. | Toyota Yaris: Strong Toyota brand reputation for durability supports better resale. | B |
Strengths
2020 Fiat 500
Iconic styling and fun driving dynamics
Higher base horsepower for peppy performance
Compact size ideal for city parking
Premium feel in a small package
2020 Toyota Yaris
Superior fuel efficiency and range
More interior and boot space
Longer 5-year warranty
Lower running costs with regular fuel
Weaknesses
2020 Fiat 500
Tighter rear passenger space
Premium fuel requirement
Shorter warranty
Higher CO2 emissions
2020 Toyota Yaris
Less powerful base engine
Less characterful design
Slightly larger for tight urban spots
Pricing Comparison
Fiat 500
€13,000 - €18,000
Toyota Yaris
€14,000 - €19,000
In Europe, 2020 Fiat 500 starts around €13,000 used, up to €18,000 for higher trims, while Yaris ranges €14,000-€19,000. Yaris offers better value with lower running costs and stronger resale, offsetting similar pricing. Fiat appeals for style but trails in efficiency.
Reliability
Fiat 500
AverageToyota Yaris
Above Average
Toyota Yaris benefits from the brand's excellent reliability reputation, supported by longer warranty and owner forums praising durability. Fiat 500 is average, with some electrical and build quality issues noted, though improved in 2020 models. Data favors Yaris for fewer repairs over time.
Best For
Fiat 500
Style-focused urban drivers seeking fun, retro charm and easy maneuvering in cities, who prioritize driving enjoyment over space.
Toyota Yaris
Practical commuters needing efficiency, reliability, more space, and low costs for daily use and family errands.
Final Verdict
Winner: 2020 Toyota Yaris
The Toyota Yaris wins overall for its superior efficiency, practicality, running costs, and reliability in the European market. While the Fiat 500 charms with style and performance, it falls short in space and long-term value. Choose Fiat for fun, Yaris for dependability.