2011 BMW 5 Series Review & Buyer's Guide
Looking up a specific BMW 5 Series?
Check VIN History ReportOverview
What Are the Strengths of the 2011 BMW 5 Series?
Excellent Highway Comfort
The 535i excels on interstates, described as serene, composed, and quiet, with a smooth ride in comfort mode.
Impressive Fuel Efficiency
Long-term testing yielded 23 mpg overall, with up to 28 mpg on highway stretches for the 535i.
Luxurious and Spacious Cabin
Cabin mirrors the 7 Series with roomy space, supportive articulated seats, and high-quality materials.
Strong Performance
Turbocharged engines deliver thrilling acceleration, blending luxury with sports car dynamics in models like the 550i.
Precise Handling
Owners love how it handles turns and ramps smoothly, feeling safe and reliable for its age.
Premium Ride Quality
Adjustable suspension provides a plush ride, especially in comfort settings, ideal for long trips.
What Are the Weaknesses of the 2011 BMW 5 Series?
Vague Electric Steering
Horrific steering lacks on-center feel and loads artificially, compromising driver confidence; software fix hoped for.
High Oil Consumption
Many owners report adding a quart of oil every 700-1000 miles, with BMW recommending more frequent changes.
Limited Cup Holders in Manual
Manual transmission models lack proper cup holders, with only a small bin and partial bolster.
Expensive Maintenance
Wear and tear issues arise with age, and ownership costs are high due to BMW parts and service.
Seat Bolster Complaints
Lack of adjustable bolsters noted by some staffers, though seats are generally supportive.
What Are the Most Common 2011 BMW 5 Series Problems?
Excessive Oil Consumption
HighN55 engine in 535i burns oil rapidly, requiring additions every 700-1000 miles; BMW adjusted service intervals.
Electric Power Steering Problems
ModerateVague on-center feel and artificial loading from electric rack; potential software reprogram fix around 40,000 miles.
General Wear and Tear
ModerateAge-related issues like suspension and interior wear common after 100,000+ miles.
Turbocharger Failures
HighTwin-turbo V8 in 550i prone to issues, contributing to multiple problems in owner reports around 80,000 miles.
High Maintenance Costs
HighFrequent services needed due to oil use and parts, escalating after 50,000 miles.
What Owners Say
Owners love the luxury, performance, and handling but are frustrated by oil consumption, steering issues, and high maintenance costs, leading to some regret over ownership.
"I fell in love with this car. A luxury car wrapped into sports package. Sadly enough, later on I learned of multiple issues." — Edmunds
"So most owners have to add a quart of oil anywhere from 700 to 1000 miles." — Edmunds
"Reliable and safe. Smooth driving. For its year, wear and tear has been the only issue. I love the way it handles turns and ramps." — SureCritic
"TUNED 2011 BMW F10 535i OWNERSHIP REVIEW...BIG MISTAKE. I'm gonna sell it." — YouTube
"It's an overall beautiful car." — SureCritic
Reliability Rating
Below AverageThe 2011 5 Series suffers from high oil use in N55/N63 engines, steering flaws, and costly repairs, dropping reliability below average despite strong driving dynamics; long-term tests show durability potential with maintenance.
Final Verdict
The 2011 BMW 5 Series offers exceptional luxury and performance for enthusiasts, with the 535i shining on highways and delivering solid efficiency. However, persistent oil consumption, steering issues, and high ownership costs make it less reliable for budget-conscious buyers. Ideal for those prioritizing driving pleasure and willing to invest in upkeep.
See price guide for the 2011 BMW 5 Series
Market values, cost of ownership, depreciation data, and buying tips.
Compare This Vehicle
Check Any BMW 5 Series VIN
Get a comprehensive history report for any 2011 BMW 5 Series
Check VIN Now